Homemade PB&J Felt Game

I love making simple homemade games and toys for my daughter – it’s a really easy way to feel like a supermom and get my crafting fix at the same time! This Homemade PB&J Game was inspired by a sweet poem by Betsy Snyder.

PBJ Homemade Game - an easy game for beginners that you can make at home! Doubles as a set of homemade felt food - and the rules of the game are easy for kids to remember.

I was inspired to make this game after reading this sweet poem in Betsy Synder’s I Haiku You:

you be my jelly,

i’ll be your peanut butter –

let’s stick together!

My daughter thought this was an adorable little haiku and she loved the fun foodie metaphor!

This simple homemade felt game is a great introduction to the basics of playing a game – rolling a dice, waiting turns, following instructions – while also being easy and straightforward for kids to remember. I also love that the felt and the felt-covered die brings in a sensory element to the game.

This game might also be a fun option for a child who misses out on peanut butter due to allergies, depending on their personality.

How to make a PB&J game - a simple game that teaches children the basics of a good game, like patience, and following the rules!

How to Make Your Own Homemade PB&J Game

First, gather your materials:

  • 3 colours of felt: one for bread, one for the peanut butter, and one for the jam. We used white, light brown, and purple for a grape jelly and peanut butter on white bread – but feel free to use your child’s favourite combination while whipping together your game
  • Sharp scissors
  • Wooden die or cube (you’re going to be covering it up with felt anyways)
  • Felt glue or school glue

Simply cut out bread-shaped pieces of your “bread felt” and splotchy blob-shapes out of the peanut butter and jam felt.

Trace the sides of the wooden die onto the different colours of felt and cut small squares to cover up the die with – you want to cover the six sides of the die with two squares of each of the three felt colours. Attach with glue. (Alternatively, you can paint the die to match – but I loved that sensory contrast of the soft felt on the hard wood.)

You can place this game in any container, but a cleaned-up peanut butter or jam jar would be fun and allow children to practice opening and closing containers!

Playing the PBJ game - a homemade felt game that teaches children how to follow simple game rules

How to Play the PB&J Game

There are two levels of play for this game – more if you want to come up with your own variations!

Way to Play #1: Gathering Ingredients

Have your child start off by rolling the die.

Identify which colour is facing up – that is the corresponding colour to the felt piece your child receives.

Take turns and encourage patience and positive attitudes towards other players.

Everyone takes turns gathering pieces until one player has 2 “bread pieces”, 1 “peanut butter” piece, and 1 “jam” piece. That player is the winner!

(Celebrating with PB&J sandwiches completely optional but definitely encouraged!)


Way to Play #2: Making the Sandwich in Order

Have your child start off by rolling the die.

Identify which colour is facing up – they need a bread piece to get started.

Take turns and encourage patience and positive attitudes towards other players.

Once the player has rolled a “bread piece” they can gather their jam and peanut butter pieces, but they cannot receive another bread piece until their first piece has both peanut butter and jam on it.

This version takes slightly longer and is intended for a child who has experience pldaying games and is ready to practice patience and delayed gratification.

Homemade PB&J Game kids will love

What do you think? Would your kids enjoy this Homemade PB & J game?
21 Awesome Valentine's Activities for Kids! Math games, ABC activities, sensory bottles... so many fun ideas in one spot!


Printable Valentine’s Day Dice Games // Fun-A-Day

FREE Number Bingo // The STEM Laboratory

Pre-Writing Alphabet Practice with Conversation Hearts // Preschool Inspirations

Heart Match Up Activity // Frogs, Snails and Puppy Dog Tails

Counting Roses // Best Toys 4 Toddlers

Conversation Heart Counting Cards // Life Over C’s

Love Bug Clock // Fairy Poppins

Counting Heart Cake Toppers // Adventures of Adam

Heart Wreath // Powerful Mothering

Magic Heart Sight Words // Playdough to Plato

Simple Suspended Conversation Heart Discovery Bottle // Lemon Lime Adventures

Valentine Numbers and Counting Hearts // Play and Learn Everyday

Valentine Math: Portable Ten Frame with Hearts // Lalymom

Teach Buttoning Skills with Heart Buttons // Sugar Aunts

Free Valentine’s Day Addition Memory Game // DIY Farm Wife

Hearts Pom Pom Game // Teach Me Mommy

I Spy Valentine’s Day Heart Bottle // The Pleasantest Thing

Color Sorting Hearts // Modern Preschool

Candy Heart Addition Cards // The Kindergarten Connection

We Go Together Like PB&J Homemade Game // Sugar, Spice and Glitter

Valentine’s Day CVC Board Game // Liz’s Early Learning Spot

Share Button

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>